Saturday, May 17, 2008

In the Soup


“It breathes reassurance, it offers consolation; after a weary day, it promotes sociability… There is nothing like a bowl of hot soup…”
~ Louis DeGouy, The Soup Book

Soup, as the word goes, is supposed to be of unknown origin. One theory which is now widely followed states that 'Soup' originates from a word 'Sop', which is today bread meant for dipping in the soup.
There are some others who quote this 'the word soup of Gothic\English of unknown origin, a cognate of Soopa (Sanskrit) is likely a cognate of Persian/Arabic, shorba/shurba/sherbet.'
Shorba can be differentiated as shor meaning salty, and ba meaning water.
Well, as a whole, shorba has its roots in Persia and it came to India along with the Mughals. Biriyani, which is a native of Persia, the meat is to be cooked in shorba (broth).

Well there is someone, who seems to think that shorba is a maharashtrian dish, and it makes me wonder.

The first time I read about Shorba was while reading Khaleed Hosseini's 'The Kite Runner'. In the last century, during Eid, people in Afghanistan used to cook shorba with red meat, and bake fresh bread to go with it. This used to be taken to the mosque for the praying people to have. After reading about it in the book, the only thing I wanted to have was Tomato shorba and the easiest way of having it was to cook it myself. For that, the first thing I required was the recipe which I got from Cooking at Pragyan's .



Tomato shorba as compared to tomato soup is very light and spicier with a lot more herbs in it. The basic difference is the addition of coconut.

I made my own with a few variations though.

Ingredients:

3-4 large tomatoes
1 tbs gram flour
1/2 cup desiccated coconut
2-3 bay leaves
3-4 green chilies
1/4 tbs cumin seeds
1-2 cloves
3-4 cloves of minced garlic
1/2 tbs ground pepper
1 tbs oil
Salt to taste
1 tbs lemon juice or 1 tbs tamarind paste diluted in 1/4 cup water
Coriander sprigs for garnishing

Procedure:

Heat 1 cup of water in a pan. Dice the tomatoes in large cubes and add them to the pan. Also add the bay leaves, cloves, garlic and coconut. Let this simmer till tomatoes become soft. As the ingredients boil they give out a delightful aroma which fills up the kitchen.

Dissolve gram flour in 2 tbs of water. No lumps.

Once the tomatoes have softened, let the pan cool down. I prefer to pass the mixture directly though the blender. In case you do not like the tomato seeds, de-seed the tomatoes while dicing them.

Heat oil in a thick bottomed pan. Splutter cumin seeds. Add the green chilies. Pour in the mixture from the blender along with the dissolved gram flour. Also the lemon juice or diluted tamarind. Let the mixture boil for a minute or two.
Add salt and pepper. Garnish with chopped coriander.
This is my entry to
1. My own event This book makes me cook
2. Ragaa's MBP: soups and salads MBP: Soups and Salads
3. Spicy Tasty's Fortune Cooking Contest. I pick up Aries and Tomatoes.
4. Also is my inaugural post for the Recipe marathon, organized by Siri and DK.


Update from the ladies participating in the Recipe Marathon
Recipe Marathon Day 1 - Menu:

Siri has entered with Baked cauliflower in Marinara sauce
DK with her Bhindi Jaipuri
Swati come with Dum Ka Murg Zafrani
Divya Vikram with a Peas Kurma
Srivalli gets Chicken Semi Gravy.
Raaga gets her Masala Lauki Chana Dal
Current mood: .......
Current song: Lemon Tree (Sting)
Current book: Wuthering Heights

17 comments:

Uma said...

Wow, the soup looks so refreshing! You covered 4 events with one entry, great idea!

Srivalli said...

wow..beautiful new look!..and I guess one strike to all events!..:)

meeso said...

Yum, My mom raised me on tons of soups and I can't eat a can of soup to this day... It has to be homemade! This looks delicious :)

Swati Raman Garg said...

bingo .. onw hit to so many events... shorba is a fav to me too... i like your style of writing...
ok i linked to your post from my 1st entry to d marathon...this run is gonna b fun i guess...

Arundathi said...

nice soup recipe. i enjoy making my own soups - and this recipe is a keeper. lovely photos...

Divya Vikram said...

lovely entry..

Siri said...

the soup looks very comforting Bhags..:D Love the new template too!!
4 birds in one shot huh?

Siri

DK said...

hey bhags,

This is amazing. Luv ur template luks cool!and hey is that soup by any chance Middle eastern...Girl this is the chance to create a record with max no. of events with one recipe. U can send that to Siri who is hosting AWED Middle Eastearn cuisine this time...of course if you are interested that is.

Luv everything I see...and super duper start for RM

Madhuram said...

The shorba looks so satisfying. I can literally smell the aroma here.

Siri said...

forgot to mention before Bhags, Could you please link up today's posts from rest of the participants too!. We all did the same. U can find the list on my blog..:) . Thanks and cya soon!

Siri

DK said...

and hey bhags..

regd ur comment for AWED, Siri is doing it jus as a favour to me since I have some serious deadlines at work and my hands are tight with so many things to take care of.

But I will sure keep you in mind , if at all I do so in future , once I start inviting all, for guest hosting . It is so sweet of you to ask though :)

Madhavi said...

Yummy looking soup, very nice recipe. Great entry :))

Jackie said...

This soup looks wonderful..and I enjoyed reading about "sop" -- thinking about it, soup really is great for dipping bread in, so it really makes sense!

Hetal said...

Ummm....the soup is very tempting!!!

Swati Raman Garg said...

hey bhags could u tell me how do i create a link to my page from your blog..iam unable to do that

Pragyan said...

Thanks for trying this! Your variation sounds cool. Glad to know as I had half-guessed that shorba is a persian word :)

Anonymous said...

Looks delicious but a linguistic correction is in order. Not that I blame you as I have seen this very same error in reputable publications that deal routinely with middle eastern issues. Shorba is an Arabic word-through and through. It comes from the arabic root sh-r-b which can be manipulated to yishrab-he drinks-and thus conjugated, mashrooob-beverages, sharbet-our sherbet also contrary to belief not a Persian word, and many other forms which stem from the typical tri-consonant arabic root. Interestingly the Hebrew(the less common of the surviving semitic tongues) word for soup is MaRaK, just as in Saudi Arabia and surrounding Arabian countries MaRaQ is used to denote a tomato based sauce. (This word is also used in east africa via the spread of Islam-much as Shoorba came to Afghanistan.)The persian for soup is "ash". Sooopa or supa is indeed the Sanskrit word from whence some indo-european languages derive soup. Note however soup in french is pottage but la sopa in Spanish. Thanks for recipe. I will try it this winter. Salaam.